缘木求鱼

yuán mù qiú yú

  • Meaning

    Literal

    To climb a tree to catch a fish

    Usage

    To be unable to realize one's goals due to improper strategy

  • Connotation

    Negative

  • Usage Examples

    不多读书写作,要想成为作家,无异于缘木求鱼 | Bù duō dúshū xiězuò, yào xiǎng chéngwéi zuòjiā, wúyìyú yuánmùqiúyú
    Trying to become a writer without frequently writing and reading is a fruitless effort
    [Source]

    要减肥就要多运动,只靠药物,无疑是缘木求鱼 | Yào jiǎnféi jiù yào duō yùndòng, zhǐ kào yàowù, wúyí shì yuánmùqiúyú
    In order to lose weight you need to exercise. Just taking pills is a fruitless approach
    [Source]

  • Equivalents

    English

    Fruitless effort/attempt

    Chinese

    None

  • Entry Notes

    None

  • Origin

    《孟子》(Mèng Zǐ), a classic Confucian work written by the philosopher of the same name. The work is often known in English as "The Book of Mencius."

  • Story

    During the Warring States Period (475 - 221 BC), 孟子 (Mèng Zǐ, Mencius) went to see the king of Qí Guó (齐国).

    "Your Majesty," said 孟子. "What is your deepest desire?"

    The king laughed, but he didn't respond, so 孟子 pushed.

    "Are there not enough fine foods to eat?" he asked. "Do you not have enough clothes to wear? Or are your attendants not dependable? If it is this you desire, your ministers will easily be able to provide it to you. Is this what it is you desire?"

    The king replied that that was not what he sought.

    "Then you want to expand your territory and rule over the central plains," said 孟子. "But I'm afraid that how you're trying to realize this goal right now is like climbing a tree to catch a fish."

    "Is it really that serious?" asked the king.

    "It's even more serious than that. If you climb a tree to fish, you'll be unsuccessful, but there will be no long-lasting repercussions. But your current efforts will certainly have a disastrous effect on top of failing to help you reach your goal."

    "Can you explain why?"

    Mencius said, "Imagine if the other states of 楚国 (Chǔ Guó) and 邹国 (Zōu Guó) were to go to war. Who would win?"

    "楚国, of course," said the king.

    "So naturally, a small county can't go up against a large country, a sparsely populated country can't resist a populous one, and a weak country can't fight a strong one. The country of 齐国 is small — what would the difference be between 齐国 going against larger countries and 邹国 going up against other countries? I urge Your Majesty to think on this some more, and focus on making your country a place that scholars, businessmen, farmers, and all walks of life will be eager to come to. That way, no one would go up against you."

  • Citations and Helpful Resources

    • 汉语成语小词典 (hànyǔ chéngyǔ xiǎo cídiǎn)
    • 现代汉语规范词典 (xiàndài hànyǔ guīfàn cídiǎn)
    • 多功能成语词典 (duō gōngnéng chéngyǔ cídiǎn)
    • 汉语大词典 (hànyǔ dà cídiǎn)
    • ABC Chinese-English Comprehensive Dictionary
    • Pleco Basic Chinese-English Dictionary
    • 语文米[x]
    • 全故事网[x]
    • 瑞文网[x]